In reviewing last year’s list, we see that the best strategy was the high P/B category which returned +5.90%, although the market propelled higher by +14.90%.
The largest gain was driven by Clorox (CLX) which, at the time, was trading at a staggering 33x of its book value. Now compare that with American National Insurance (ANAT) which was trading at 0.55x book value. The stock fell -31%.
On average, 3 stocks trading below book value lost -20% of its value in one year. This is the observation we see and simply reporting on the data. The table is a summary table for various strategies.
November 15, 2019 | ||
Strategy | High | Low |
Yield | -23.6% | 4.7% |
P/E | 1.1% | -30.9% |
Payout Ratio |
-3.4% | -21.7% |
P/B | 5.9% | -28.8% |
Closest to Low |
3.4% | |
S&P 500 |
14.9% | |
Dow Jones Ind |
5.3% | |
Top 5 companies except for Index |
Again, we continue to see the traditional value approach underperform.
U.S. Dividend Watch List: November 13, 2020
We saw another all-time high for the market this week. If the Dow Industrial and S&P 500 can consolidate and hold this level, it will be very bullish. This strong market is the reason why there are only 4 companies on our list. Continue reading