Category Archives: Margin Debit-Credit

Margin Debit-Credit: August 2023

Below is the Year-Over-Year percentage change data from FINRA’s Margin Statistics. Continue reading

1997-2021: Margin Debit/Credit

image

It appears that the market for margin debt is moderating.  Still unclear is the pattern of Debit to peak in March 2000, June 2007, and March 2021.  The pattern so far is to collapse into a market low.  The distinction in 2000 and 2007 is that there were several years of market increases leading up to each peak.  We suspect the current peak is a result of the pandemic.  It is possible that the Credit indication is more reliable for correlations with the stock market.

When the Fed Tried But Couldn’t Crush Stocks

By the logic of many, the stock market is being propped by the Federal Reserve.  How is the Fed propping the stock market? Pushing interest rates down and keeping them down and possibly considering going negative on rates.

As we’ve consistently maintained, the Fed doesn’t matter.  The following is an example of when it appeared as though the Fed was doing everything in their power to undermine the rise in the stock market.

image

The standard arguments to the increase of the Dow Jones Industrial Average include the New Deal programs implemented in 1933 and/or WWII which began in 1939.  These claims sound good but don’t quite explain the reversal of the Dow Jones Industrial Average in July 1932.

If the claim is that the Fed is propping the stock market now then it is because an examination of the extensive history of rate increases from 1942 to 1968 hasn’t been reviewed.

Finally, if the claim is that the Fed is bound and determined to use every tool in the playbook to increase the stock market, then by the record of the period from 1934 to 1971, we should see the discount rate increase ten times and a constant fiddling with the margin rate.

It is possible that the low rates and unlimited “stimulus” measure is actually capping the rise of the stock market.

Margin Debit-Credit: August 2020

Below is the Year-Over-Year percentage change data from FINRA’s Margin Statistics.

image

see also: Margin Debit-Credit August 2019

Margin Debit-Credit: August 2019

Below is the Year-Over-Year percentage change data from FINRA’s Margin Statistics.

image

We’ve combined the data that ends in January 2010 with the data that begins in February 2010 from the same data source.  The dates on the chart generally coincide with market peaks and trough.