Members
-
Topics
Archives
-
-
Recent Posts
-
-
Investor Education
Market Return After Exceptional Years
Dollar Cost Averaging Tool
Dow Theory: The Formation of a Line
Dividend Capture Strategy Analysis
Golden Cross – How Golden Is It?
Debunked – Death Cross
Work Smart, Not Hard
Charles H. Dow, Father of Value Investing
It's All About the Dividends
Dow Theory: Buying in Scales
How to Avoid Losses
When Dividends are Canceled
Cyclical and Secular Markets
Inflation Proof Myth
What is Fair Value?
Issues with P-E Ratios
Beware of Gold Dividends
Gold Standard Myth
Lagging Gold Stocks?
No Sophisticated Investors
Dollar down, Gold up?
Problems with Market Share
Aim for Annualized Returns
Anatomy of Bear Market Trade
Don’t Use Stop Orders
How to Value Earnings
Low Yields, Big Gains
Set Limits, Gain More
Ex-Dividend Dates -
-
Historical Data
1290-1950: Price Index
1670-2012: Inflation Rate
1790-1947: Wholesale Price Cycle
1795-1973: Real Estate Cycle
1800-1965: U.S. Yields
1834-1928: U.S. Stock Index
1835-2019: Booms and Busts
1846-1895: Gold/Silver Value
1853-2019: Recession/Depression Index
1860-1907: Most Active Stock Average
1870-2033: Real Estate Cycles
1871-2020: Market Dividend Yield
1875-1940: St. Louis Rents
1876-1934: Credit-New Dwellings
1896-1925: Inflation-Stocks
1897-2019: Sentiment Index
1900-1903: Dow Theory
1900-1923: Cigars and Cigarettes
1900-2019: Silver/Dow Ratio
1901-2019: YoY DJIA
1903-1907: Dow Theory
1906-1932: Barron's Averages
1907-1910: Dow Theory
1910-1913: Dow Theory
1910-1936: U.S. Real Estate
1910-2016: Union Pacific Corp.
1914-2012: Fed/GDP Ratio
1919-1934: Barron's Industrial Production
1920-1940: Homestake Mining
1921-1939: US Realty
1922-1930: Discount Rate
1924-2001: Gold/Silver Stocks
1927-1937: Borden Co.
1927-1937: National Dairy Products
1927-1937: Union Carbide
1928-1943: Discount Rate
1929-1937: Monsanto Co.
1937-1969: Intelligent Investor
1939-1965: Utility Stocks v. Interest Rates
1941-1967: Texas Pacific Land
1947-1970: Inventory-Sales Ratio
1948-2019: Profits v. DJIA
1949-1970: Dow 600? SRL
1958-1976: Gold Expert
1963-1977: Farmland Values
1971-2018: Nasdaq v. Gold
1971-1974: REIT Crash
1972-1979: REIT Index Crash
1986-2018: Hang Seng Index Cycles
1986-2019: Crude Oil Cycles
1999-2017: Cell Phone Market Share
2008: Transaction History
2010-2021: Bitcoin Cycles -
Interesting Read
Inside a Moneymaking Machine Like No Other
The Fuzzy, Insane Math That's Creating So Many Billion-Dollar Tech Companies
Berkshire Hathaway Shareholder Letters
Forex Investors May Face $1 Billion Loss as Trade Site Vanishes
Why the oil price is falling
How a $600 Million Hedge Fund Disappeared
Hedge Fund Manager Who Remembers 1998 Rout Says Prepare for Pain
Swiss National Bank Starts Negative
Tice: Crash is Coming...Although
More on Edson Gould (PDF)
Schiller's CAPE ratio is wrong
Double-Digit Inflation in the 1970s (PDF)
401k Crisis
Quick Link Archive
Category Archives: NUGT
Gold Stock Indicator: Short-term signal is down
Today we’ve received an indication that on a short-term basis, the direction for gold stocks is down.
As can be seen in the chart of our Gold Stock Indicator, the long-term buy indication has been triggered with the added bonus of a significant double-bottom on May 15th and July 23rd. This suggests that the long-term trend in the price for the Philadelphia Gold and Silver Stock Index (XAU) is up. However, as with any trend up or down, there are going to be counter-trend moves. Already, there have been five buy signals for gold stocks even though the overall trend has been down since November 2010.
Regarding the short-term Gold Stock Indicator being down:
-
For speculators, this means that DUST is a buy. The minimum downside risk DUST is $30 and could potentially decline to as low as $25. Remember, both DUST and NUGT are intended to be utilized for short periods of time.
-
Holders of Agnico-Eagle (AEM) should sell their position in this stock as it has increased over +40% since our April 8, 2012 recommendation (found here). It is suggested that only the principal is sold while the profit is allowed to grow risk-free.
NUGT: A “buy” signal eminent
For those willing to speculate with a portion of their funds based on the movement of gold stocks, the Direxion Daily Gold Miners Bull 3X Shares (NUGT) is about to signal a short & long-term buy indication. We believe this indication will be registered be when NUGT declines below $7.60. The $7.60 figure seems approximate, however, may change based on market conditions. Your best confirmation of what we think is an appropriate level to buy NUGT should be based on our Transaction Alert.
As we’ve indicated before, we believe that a decline of –30% or more would not be unexpected for NUGT before achieving the average gain of +20% from the initial “buy” signal. Our strategy for this next indication is to set aside 1/3 of the amount for the initial signal to buy. If NUGT declines by an additional -15% then we’d buy more shares of NUGT with the remaining 2/3 of available funds set aside. An example of how this would play out with $3,000 set aside for this speculation from May 3, 2012 for a 20% rise above the initial “buy” signal is as follows:
-
buy $1,000 (1/3) at $11.06 sell and at 20% gain ($13.27)
-
buy $2,000 (2/3) at $9.40 or below then sell at $13.27
-
the average cost would be $9.90
-
a total gain of +34% would be possible if sold at $13.27, or 20% above the initial entry price.
Our purchase of the Direxion Daily Gold Miners Bull 3X Shares (NUGT) is strictly a speculation which we will sell soon after it has achieved our target amount. Direxion’s DUST and NUGT ETFs are strictly for speculators (short-term) and should not be entered into for investment (long-term) purposes.
NUGT: Where to Now?
After posting our Gold Stock Indicator article on April 4th (found here) and suggesting that a low would be achieved between April 4th and June 7th, the actual low was hit on May 15th. This was well within the indicated date range that a major low would be achieved.
The run-up from the low was on April 15th and generated gains of +67%. Additionally, from when the short-term buy indication was first hit on May 3, 2012, the gain was +21%. We weren't savvy enough to get all of the gains from the indicated low, however, the Gold Stock Indicator appears to be hitting its marks with ease.
At the current pace, our Gold Stock Indicator has a tentative downside target for NUGT of $6.00 before it crosses simultaneously below both the long-term and short-term buy indications, as seen in the chart below. The estimated time-frame for this downside target is approximately 1 and 1/2 months from now.
We expect that the conservative gain of +21% should be expected from NUGT once it first crosses below the short-term buy indication line. Significant downside movement would still remain as was the case after the May 3rd crossing below the short-term buy indication. The amount of decline after the May 3rd indication was -28%, however, the subsequent gains of +21% was achieved in 35 calendar days while the bottom on May 15th achieved gains of 67% in exactly 30 calendar days.
As a caveat, in the same April 4th article, we indicated that “our worst case scenario for a bottom in gold stocks is the period between June 15, 2012 and August 21, 2012.” Presently, it appears that we are on course to achieve such a worse case situation based on the reversal of the rising trend of the Gold Stock Indicator. Our definition of worse case means a gold price of $1,200 to $1,300 and a NUGT price of $4 or less.
Gold Stock Indicator Update
Our Gold Stock Indicator, as seen below, is going on an interesting ride.
On May 27, 2012 (found here), we did an appraisal of the gold situation and said the following:
“…in all instances of an initial ‘short-term buy indication’ [green arrow] (except August 8, 2011), the Gold Stock Indicator was followed by a second opportunity to buy [red arrow] NUGT, sometimes at lower levels.”
In the chart above, we show a red arrow between May 3rd and June 28th. It is important to take note of the fact that even though the Gold Stock Indicator is currently at the exact same level as on May 3rd, the price of NUGT is more than $1.00 below the May price.
So far, it appears that NUGT is on course to provide us with the second opportunity to take a position, as we have anticipated. In prior moves from the short-term buy indication to the short-term sell indication, the Gold Stock Indicator has “double dipped.” By double-dip we mean that the price of NUGT has declined the short-term buy indication a second time before making an assault on the long-term sell indication.
Our only question at this time is how far must NUGT fall before it reaches the short-term buy level. If the most recent comparison between May 3rd and June 28th is any indication, then it is possible that NUGT could decline as low as $6.
Transaction Review on NUGT, A Simple Lesson Learned
This posting is in response to a great question posted by Sandesh. On May 25th, Sandesh asked, “Any update on NUGT now that it is recovered?” The chart below should say it all:
Our May 3rd transaction alert (found here) informed readers that we had taken a position in NUGT based on our Gold Stock Indicator falling below both the short and long term buy indications. In our initial transaction alert, we set the parameters when we would buy more and/or sell our position. Then, on May 6th, we revised and expanded the parameters to buy and sell (found here), based on our confidence of the indicator and the investment product.
Our revised parameters said the following:
-
50% of the amount we wish to invest now (done)
-
50% of the amount we wish to invest after a decline of -20%
-
we’re exiting the transaction after a total loss of -40% or greater
-
we’re exiting the transaction when the next short-term signal buy DUST is indicated.
We entered NUGT at $11.13. If we followed our rules, as laid out in our revised parameters, we would have bought more NUGT at $8.96 and sold out of the transaction if the ETF fells as low as $6.65. Our average gain would have been +13%. Had we remained in the position without buying additional amounts then we’d have a gain of +3.14%.
We believe that we have learned the lessons from our speculative forays with NUGT. The first lesson is, “stick to the plan.” We expect to implement the same parameters in our next transaction for both NUGT or DUST.
Note: Thanks go to Sandesh for initiating our response.
Our Current Gold Stock Indicator Analysis:
In the chart below, you will notice that in all instances of an initial “short-term buy indication” [green arrow] (except August 8, 2011), the Gold Stock Indicator was followed by a second opportunity to buy [red arrow] NUGT, sometimes at lower levels.
It is important to note that our assessment of a second opportunity to buy NUGT only occurs when the indicator does not immediately go to the short-term gold stock sell indication. We believe that, due to our Dow Theory indication that the bear market rally has ended (found here), we are on the cusp of a major stock market decline.
As we’ve stated many times in the past, gold and gold stocks generally cannot move higher in the face of a declining stock market. Therefore, we believe that gold and gold stocks are enjoying a temporary advance and will ultimately succumb to the forces of general decline in stock market. Therefore, we’re willing to accept the lesson of our latest NUGT transaction for either the second signal to buy NUGT or the next signal to buy DUST.
Note: In the chart above, we first calculated the expected downside target back in our Feb. 7, 2012 posting (found here). We’re surprise that, at least for now, that our assessment was correct. We’re hopeful that our analysis of a “double bottom” is correct as well.
Transaction Alert
We were wrong about our speculation in NUGT. Therefore, we plan to sell NUGT if it declines to $8.79.
We bought NUGT based on the dual (short and long-term) indication from our Gold Stock Indicator as indicated in our April 4, 2012 article (found here).
Our preference for using Direxion Gold Miners Bull (NUGT) and Direxion Gold Miners Bear (DUST) ETFs are not for the risk averse. DUST and NUGT are speculative vehicles and not investments meant to be held on a long-term basis.
Transaction Alert: Sold NUGT
We have sold our positions of NUGT.
Transaction Alert: Sold AEM & GFI, Bought NUGT
We have sold our positions in AEM and GFI and used the proceeds from those transactions to buy NUGT. We sold both AEM and GFI at a loss of slightly more than -5%. We decided not to over-concentrate in one sector by adding a third gold position.
We bought NUGT based on the dual (short and long-term) indication from our Gold Stock Indicator as indicated in our April 4, 2012 article (found here).
Our preference for using Direxion Gold Miners Bull (NUGT) and Direxion Gold Miners Bear (DUST) ETFs aren’t for the risk averse. DUST and NUGT are speculative vehicles and not investments meant to be held on a long term basis.
Gold Stock Indicator Points Up
Today at 12:10pm EST, our gold stock indicator signaled that gold stocks were reasonably undervalued. This indication occurred just after the price of gold started a sharp rise in price today and just before gold stocks started to jump, as indicated in the intraday chart below:
As indicated in our Transaction Alert today (April 10, 2012), we bought Newmont Mining (NEM) as a “long term” holding in gold stocks. Our view of the long term is predicated on the percentage gain that is achieved and the alternative stocks that appear undervalued at the time. If the gain has been exceptional in a reasonable period of time and there are better values elsewhere then we may jump ship.
Despite our confidence in the Gold Stock Indicator, we believe that it is necessary to have reasonable expectations for any of the stocks suggested. This means carefully examine the downside risk. As an example, it took Agnico-Eagle (AEM) a little over 1 year to achieve +174%. In that time, AEM traded in a narrow range for a majority of the time and fell almost -30% before reaching such astronomical heights.
Our purchase of the Direxion Daily Gold Miners Bull 3X Shares (NUGT) is strictly a speculation which we will sell soon after it has achieved a gain of +7.5%. Our examination of 3x gold ETFs (DUST and NUGT) is that a gain of +7.5% is achieved 85% of the time, based on 80 transactions initiated by our Gold Stock Indicator since 1983. Direxion’s DUST and NUGT ETFs are strictly for speculators (short-term) and should not be entered into for investment (long-term) purposes. You have been warned.
Our last Gold Stock Indicator signal can be found here: Gold Stock Indicator Points Down
Posted in AEM, DUST, Gold Stock Indicator, NUGT