Category Archives: Speed Resistance Lines

Gamestop Downside Targets

Based on the work of Edson Gould, we have determined the downside targets for GameStop Corp. (GME) covering data from the last two years.  To arrive at conclusions that are reasonable, we first must determine precedent for the potential declines.

2002-2012

image

In the period from 2002-2007, GameStop Corp. increased to a high of $63.30 which established the following downside targets:

  • $28.28 (conservative target)
  • $24.69 (mid-range target)
  • $21.10 (extreme target)

The actual low was $15.73 in 2012.

2012-2020

image

In the period from 2012-2020, GameStop Corp. increased to a high of $57.43 which established the following downside targets:

  • $41.81 (conservative target)
  • $30.50 (mid-range target)
  • $19.20 (extreme target)

The actual low was $2.80 in 2020.

2020-2021

image

In the period from 2020-2021, GameStop Corp. increased to a high of $39.91 which established the following downside targets:

  • $21.26 (conservative target)
  • $18.22 (mid-range target)
  • $15.17 (extreme target)

If GameStop were to replicate the rise of 2002-2007, the price could easily achieve a level of $47.40 before a significant decline ensues.  However, achieving such a high price would still relegate the stock to the conservative downside target of $21.26.

The only action we take on downside targets is re-examination of the company fundamentals with an eye for acquiring a long position in the company in question.  We do not attempt to short the stock in any form.

Tesla Downside Targets

Review

We have run Tesla Downside targets in the past.

All parabolic moves get corrected by a specific amount, at minimum.  Because a declining trend has begun, we have run the numbers of the expected downside targets based on Edson Gould’s Speed Resistance Lines.

image

The targets are:

  • $238.35
  • $202.23
  • $166.11

The previous FAILED downside targets had significant problems that could have been easily remedied. First and foremost, for highly volatile stocks like Tesla, we did not include downside targets assuming the price would double.  This is usually the most likely scenario to play out and is best represented in our September 13, 2018 targets for Tilray (TLRY).

At the time, Tilray was trading at $118 and we had laid out our downside targets for the stock as seen for Tesla above.  However, acknowledging the psychological component of the change in the price, we included downside targets for Tilray if the price doubled ($236) [within the chart].  In fact, Tilray did double shortly afterwards and the downside targets for the doubled level were achieved, by a wide margin.

The doubling downside targets for TSLA are (assumes $996.64 peak):

  • $404.45
  • $368.33
  • $332.21

We’re glad to have failed the previous times as it refines and teaches what we need to know about the limits of Edson Gould’s work.  We hope to continue the process of learning as we teach.

See also:

Top three downside targets achieved by year

2020

2019

2018

2017

2016

Tesla Downside Targets

Below are the downside targets for Tesla Inc. (TSLA) as of July 7, 2020.

image

  • $824.51 (conservative target)
  • $643.90 (mid-range target)
  • $463.29 (extreme target)

Parabolic increases rarely go unchecked.  This typically means that a decline to the conservative downside target is the norm, at minimum.  However, Tesla has had a history of defying the “norm” when it comes to price change.

see also: TSLA downside targets achieved

Twilio Inc. Downside Targets

Below are the downside support lines for Twilio Inc. (TWLO) from 2016 to 2017:

image

  • $60.92
  • $41.96
  • $22.99

Below are the downside support lines for 2017 to 2020: Continue reading

Simon Property Group SRL

Markets are built on precedent.  For this reason, we will display the downside targets in two prior periods to establish the history for Simon Property Group before getting to the most recent decline.  We also provide the upside resistance targets for those hoping to “play” the move to the upside.

To get yourself familiar with the work of Edson Gould’s Speed Resistance Lines, we recommend that you review the our article titled “The Power and Lesson of Speed Resistance Lines” dated February 4, 2018.  Since that article, approximately 90% of the Speed Resistance Lines that we have run have come to fruition.

Simon Property Group Downside Targets

1993-2000

image

The mid-range target is a point to watch as it generally defines the balance of the direction of the stock price.  Notice how SPG managed to rise and then decline below the prior low.

1999-2009

image

As should be expected, the decline in the run from the 2007 peak was almost down to the prior starting point as the decline was generally a result of the malinvestment in the real estate sector.  As noted in the chart, SPG managed to not replicated the prior cycle of decline from 1998 to 1999.  However, it did get pretty close.

2008-2020

image

The decline from the 2016 peak should not be unfamiliar since it is almost a replication of the decline from 2007 to 2009.  If the current decline were to replicated the 2007-2009 decline, it would bring the price of SPG to $34.16.  This number is not too far from the $36.04 level indicated by the price-to-dividend ratio as outlined in the 10-Year Target that was previously posted.

Upside Resistance Targets

2016-2020

image

Assuming that the $34.16 price is the downside target and investors are willing to accept such a risk, the upside targets are very compelling.  The first upside target is $135.81, or nearly 100% above the current price of $70.  However, anyone willing to participate in the potential decline to $34.16 need to accept that rising to $197.31 is still within the declining trend which could conceivably result in a decline back to the $44.01 price.

Our primary concern is with downside risk and therefore if a real estate investment trust must be bought at this time then we’d prefer a position in the Vanguard Real Estate Index Fund (VNQ) over individual names where the volatility is far above our tolerance levels.

see also: U.S. Realty from 1918 to 1945

Microsoft Downside Targets

Below are the Speed Resistance Lines for Microsoft (MSFT) from 1990 to 2002.

image

From 1993 to 2002, Microsoft experienced a similar parabolic peak to the 2009 to 2020 period.  In that time, MSFT hit all of the downside targets that are generated by our Speed Resistance Lines. 

Below we outline the Speed Resistance Lines for Microsoft from 2009 to 2020. Continue reading

Shopify Downside Targets

Below are the downside targets for Shopify (SHOP):

image

  • $300.17 (conservative target)
  • $240.62 (mid-range target)
  • $181.07 (extreme target)

The history of parabolic increases suggests that Shopify’s mid-range target of $240.62 is not unusual and the extreme downside target is possible.  We’ll update this chart upon request.

Review: Mercury General

On November 20, 2015, we posted the Speed Resistance Lines for Mercury General (MCY).  The downside targets were:

  • $53.96 (conservative target)
  • $37.03 (mid-range target)
  • $20.10 (extreme target)

The chart below highlights the date the SRL was published and the price action that has transpired since November 20, 2015.

image

Our lurking worry? That the $20.10 target will be achieved.  This leads to a downside range of $18-$20 from the current price of $38.88.

Review: Hospitality Properties Trust

On June 3, 2015, we said the following of Hospitality Properties Trust (renamed to Service Properties Trust):

“If worse comes to worse, HPT could decline to point A or $13.00.  If a repeat of the housing crisis were to take place then HPT could decline as low as point B or $4.67.”

The chart below highlights the date the article was published and the price action that has transpired since June 2015.

image

The worst case target was achieved by an exceptionally wide margin.

DJIA: Downside Targets

On February 3, 2018, we said the following:

“In the past, we would normally apply the more passive Dow Theory downside targets instead of Edson Gould’s Speed Resistance Line.  However, with the late stage parabolic move in the Dow Jones Industrial Average, the more aggressive downside targets are necessary in this instance.”

Our decision to utilize the “more aggressive downside targets” has proven to be well founded.  However, since the February 3, 2018, a new peak has been achieved which provides different downside targets.  This leads to an update of the downside and upside targets.

Below are the updates with extensive review of what to watch for (skip to the bottom for the Summary). Continue reading

SPDR Gold Shares Downside Targets

Below are the downside targets for the SPDR Gold Shares (GLD).

image

  • $124.16 (intermediate target)
  • $106.27 (mid-range target)
  • $52.60 (extreme target)

The $124.16 level is not an “official” downside level as it is only an intermediate point on the way to the actual level of $106.27.  As we’ve seen in the past, the extreme downside target is always the concern.  For GLD the extreme downside target is $52.60.

Top three stocks, commodities, or indexes that achieved our downside targets by year:

2020

2019

2018

2017

2016

How do we use Speed Resistance Lines? Once a target is achieved we assess the possibility of investment.  If the target is not achieved we move on to the next stock. 

There are approximately 15% to 20% of the SRLs  that we’ve run that haven’t come to fruition, yet.  However, in this current market decline, many that weren’t fulfilled are now getting completed.

Update: Tesla Inc. Targets

When Tesla (TSLA) was trading at $734.70, we said the following:

“Parabolic increases rarely go unchecked.  This typically means that a decline to the conservative downside target is the norm, at minimum.  However, Tesla has had a history of defying the “norm” when it comes to price change.”

At that time, February 5, 2020, we provided the following downside targets:

  • $507.09 (conservative target)
  • $401.39 (mid-range target)
  • $295.69 (extreme target)

Seventeen days after our downside price targets, the price of TSLA increased as high as $917.42 on a closing basis.  The increase in price marginally affected the downside targets for TSLA.  So far, Tesla has achieved two of the three downside targets and looks to easily achieve the last target (extreme downside target).

Below are the updated downside targets for Tesla Inc. (TSLA).

image

  • $517.21 (conservative target)
  • $411.51 (mid-range target)
  • $305.81 (extreme target)

Pendulums swing from one extreme to another.  We’ll watch to see if the extreme to the upside is matched on the downside.

Acceleron Downside Targets

Below are the downside targets for Acceleron Pharma Inc. (XLRN).

image

  • $65.39 (conservative target)
  • $48.58 (mid-range target)
  • $31.77 (extreme target)

Virgin Galactic Downside Targets

Below are the downside targets for Virgin Galactic Holdings (SPCE).

image

  • $25.54 (conservative target)
  • $19.85 (mid-range target)
  • $14.16 (extreme target)

Virgin Galactic Holdings (SPCE) is creating a scenario where the extreme downside target could easily be achieved while being considered a normal “bounce.” The price would have to rise to above $60 before the above downside targets are no longer valid.

These situations don’t end well but in case the price doubles from the recent peak we provide the following downside targets.

  • $39.71 (conservative target)
  • $34.02 (mid-range target)
  • $28.33 (extreme target)

WorkDay Downside Targets

Below are the downside targets for WorkDay Inc. (WDAY).

image

  • $140.86 (conservative target)
  • $107.81 (mid-range target)
  • $74.77 (extreme target)

The downside targets are based on the peak price of $224.30.  In our view, WorkDay failed to achieve the minimum downside target of the ascending level at $140.86.  In many respects, this reflects the strength of buyers.  However, this failure would not have allowed us to take advantage of the reversal that has occurred since the $152.29 low. 

With this in mind, we have posted the upside resistance targets based on the October 23, 2019 low.  These target are meant to confirm the strength of the rise and the potential for additional gains/losses going forward.