On August 24, 2009, we posted a blurb on Suburban Propane (SPH) titled “Suburban Propane (SPH) Says, ‘Just Add Water’”. In that piece, we suggested that the shares of SPH were overvalued with the following commentary:
“SPH basically said that it was going to pay down debt with the money raised from the sale of the stock. So what they're doing is watering down the stock (diluting per share earnings) in a maneuver known as ‘Robbing Peter to Pay Paul’ method of accounting. You've got to admit, it is a great strategy from the perspective of the company with overvalued shares but current shareholders are getting the shaft.”
Since August 2009, SPH has followed along a rollercoaster ride going as high as $58 in 2011 and most recently as low as $20.93.
As the stock has decline over –40% since our August 2009 posting, we believe now is a good time to review SPH.